| Okay, so there's this one thing I really love about Passover. There is absolutely no way you can get through a Sedar without being told about what God did for you when he delivered YOU from the land of Egypt. Yes, folks - it's true! Even you, a lowly American Jew can experience servitude, desert wandering and mana that falls from the sky!
Now, it's not that I am missing the point - I get it. Once again we Jews are tracking lineage. If my parents parents parents parents parents parents(^3) hadn't left Egypt, then technically, I'd be chillin' there too. Even still, I have to love this one part of the sedar where there are four sons who ask some questions about Passover. There's a wise son who wants to know about the laws from God regarding Passover. There's a simple son who must be kind of checked out since all he thinks to asks is "what's this?". There's even a son who doesn't know how to ask.
What really kills me, though, is the wicked son. He asks "What does this drudgery mean to you" The crux of this is that he says you and not us, a grave offence to any semantically inclinded jew (i.e. - all of us), since it seems to imply that he doesn't consider himself among those God personally delivered from Egypt.
I can imagine what must have been going through this kids head last April. He's sitting there, trying to remember all the vacations he's been on, every house he's lived in. "Can't say I recall leaving the tri-state area. I don't really remember any servitude or brick laying, either. And you sure as heck can't tell me I was dragged across the desert for 40 years. I'm only 14, dude! Are you sure you've got your dates right - has any one checked Wikipedia about this?" All of a sudden his show off big brother (destined to be a lawyer, I'm sure) starts asking about the rules of Passover. Can't he just wait 'til after dinner and google them or something?
Not wanting to be shown up though, he figures he'll ask something too. He's already established that he's never been to Egypt, but who knows - Mom and Dad look pretty old, maybe they have... So he asks "What does this drudgery mean to you?", thinking they might pull out some photo albums, show him the first pyramid they worked on together. Instead he gets totally ragged on, labeled wicked, accused of insolence, and basically deemed an inferior Jew.
I mean, here we are - a highly intelligent group of people stereotyped for revering doctors and lawyers, and one of our best kept traditions involves dissing the dude with enough brains and balls to bother asking about the one thing we've all secretly been thinking. Most of my family's from Canada, I am pretty positive not a one of us has ever lived in Egypt. And to be honest, if not Moses, then the Europeans almost definetly would have kicked that Pharoah out of power. I appreciate the sentiment and all, but the only place I've been delivered from is my mother's womb.
So instead of praising a kid with enough smart-assery to be the next Allen, Sandler, or Seinfeld, we hang him out to dry. This kid must be sitting there wondering .."I guess I understand if they like Max's question better, but if he really wants to be a lawyer, wouldn't he be better off asking about local ordinances? Why isn't Dan in trouble for not even paying attention to what Dad was saying? And how can I be a worse Jew than a 3 year old? Aaron hasn't even had his Bar Mitzvah yet. He's not even in Sunday school!"
I guess there really is no one better at guilting than the Jews...
Now, what I would really love would be to be in Egypt with my family during Passover next year. That way I could lean in towards my sister after we sing the first verse of Dayenu and ask "Hey, um, Kara .. about that whole God bringing us out of Egypt line. Aren't we, ah, in Cairo right now?" |